Pink = Girl, Blue = Boy, Green = Gender Neutral?

As a needleworker who makes a lot of baby clothes for sale I am always plagued by what fabrics to buy for my custom creations. While it may not seem like a monumental issue, but when trying to appeal to parents of children it is more complex than some think.

lapped3withhatMany parents are adamant about dressing their new baby girls in pink with ribbons and bows and flowers.

They will not consent to a fabric choice unless it is girly with ruffles and pink.

The same parents who insist on pink for their baby girls are much less choosey for their baby boys.

Sure, there are those who insist on the stereotypical blue, but most will dress their boys in pretty much any color, except pink.

And, then there are all the green and the “gender neutral fabrics” that are supposed to appeal to both sexes, but, in actuality, most people perceive them as “for boys” since they don’t include pink.kimono3withhat (1)

Why are our genders so dictated by specific colors?

Why is it when someone sees a baby dressed in blue they assume immediately it’s a boy?

And, why is it when a baby girl doesn’t have some obvious signal she’s a girl, like a bow in her hair, or dressed in head to tow ruffles, she is mistaken for a boy?

These were the types of questions I was pondering while reading The Underground Girls of Kabul: In Search of a Hidden Resistance in Afghanistan, by Jenny Nordberg.

She discusses a society where boys are so much more worthy than girls that a select few families choose to dress one of their young daughters’ like a boy, and, by some magic, she becomes their son.

Pants, instead of a skirt. Short hair instead of long hair, and now this female child has access to a “man’s only” world in one of the most female oppressed societies.

How is it pants and short hair can transform a girl into a boy in this culture? It seems extreme, but dress a 5 year old girl in a dinosaur shirt and shorts with shorter hair and many in the town where I live in South Central US will think she’s a boy too.

Put a boy in a pink dress, and even with short hair, he will be mistaken for a girl.

woodlandknitonesies2Onesies for a Girl? A Boy? Either?

Why? Why are our identities so wrapped up in the clothes we wear?

Or the length of our hair?

Why is it my son thought a boy in his Sports Skills class was a girl because he had slightly long hair, even though he dressed “like a boy” and acted like a boy?

Why is it so many people told me my daughter was a cute little baby boy when she was not wearing pink, or purple?

So, you can see my dilemma. I think rockets and robots and campers are for girls and boys.

I think elephants and mustaches, and 3 Little Pigs are for girls and boys.

I think a boy can wear pink or purple if he wants, just like a girl can wear blue.

My daughter prances around in camouflage dinosaur pajamas (the kiddos’ call them dinoflage – clever huh?) showing me how the Ornithomimus runs, while my son dons a pink tutu with rose petals on it, a skunk hat and a sword and pretends he is a ballerina skunk pirate.

I had a friend in Boston who’s son would only wear pink Crocs and wanted to borrow his best friend’s (a girl) dress. His father did not want him to leave the house because he did not want his son mistaken for a girl, even though he was clearly a boy.

I met a little girl at a party who was dressed in a plaid button up shirt and jeans. Everyone there, including me when I first met her, thought she was a boy. I was disappointed in myself for assuming gender based on her outfit. Especially since, as a former tomboy myself, I dressed very similar at the same age, and even sported the same short haircut.

In the end, why does it matter so much how we dress? Why must it influence such a integral part of who we are, such as gender? Why can’t we wear what we like?


This post was inspired by The Underground Girls of Kabul by journalist Jenny Nordberg, who discovers a secret Afghani practice where girls are dressed and raised as boys. Join From Left to Write on September 16th as we discuss The Underground Girls of Kabul. As a member, I received a copy of the book for review purposes.


6 thoughts on “Pink = Girl, Blue = Boy, Green = Gender Neutral?

  1. Sounds like an interesting book!

    Other people’s perceptions will always affect clothing choices whether we like it or not. Just as you would never expect to get a nice corporate job wearing your flannel pajamas to an interview, you would get funny looks if you showed up to a casual swim party wearing a suit and tie. There are just some societal rules to how and where you wear certain things.

    Costumers are constantly having to follow (and sometimes break!) these rules accordingly. Character wearing white = good. Character wearing black = bad. That’s the over-simplified example but when you deviate from the rules you might create those “plot twists” that life is full of or just plain confuse the audience.

    All that being said, I love it when kids have fun putting on things that are outside the norm and are creative with clothing. Learning the “rules” and when it’s okay to break them is what being a kid is all about. I was once a football player for Halloween as a kid (3rd grade maybe?) – I borrowed the uniform (pads, helmet and all) from a friend who played on a team. I had a grand time confusing my friends that night as I trick-or-treated. =)

  2. Pingback: Book Club Discussion: The Underground Girls of Kabul - From Left to Write

  3. This drives me batty! I didn’t want to dress my daughter in pink and it was difficult to find clothes that weren’t pink for a baby. It must doubly hard for your to try to guess what your customers want.

  4. According to my mom, I was definitely that baby that everyone thought was a boy. She said she used to dress me in pink a lot, and because I was bald, everyone STILL thought I was a boy. Pink is pretty close to my least favorite color now–it ranks right above beige and taupe. I wouldn’t say I’m a tomboy in any sense of the word, but I love blue and geeky things, and I hope any daughters I might eventually have will be proud to like more stereotypically “boy” things if they want to.

  5. It must be very difficult for you to choose the fabrics, but I like all the ones in your picture, they could be either boy or girl. My mom hates the color pink and she refused to dress us in pink, but then again she hated yellow and wouldn’t let us wear it. So in most baby pictures my sister and I are wearing red, which was moms fav color. The boys all had either white or blue or green as that really was all that was available way back when.

  6. I remember back when my daughter was a few months old, I had dressed her in a purple and white tie-dyed onesie with blue jean overalls. Keep in mind that she had a full head of dark hair right from birth. She was still mistaken for a boy at the drug store. That same onesie made my son look “girlie” and he didn’t wear it much. I think I dressed my kids in the obvious boy/girl clothes to keep MY feelings from being hurt.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s